Promotion and Relegation
• Author(s): Stefan Szymanski & Stephen Ross
• Published: June 2001
• Pages in paper: 12
Abstract
One of the most distinctive differences between team sports in Europe and
North America is the institution of promotion and relegation. This paper looks
into the history of why this institution developed in Europe but not North
America, and considers what effects it may have on the competitive balance of the leagues. While dominance of the leagues by a small number of wealthy teams
is a more severe problem in Europe, its effects are mitigated by the opportunity
for new teams to enter from below and the excitement generated by the struggle
for survival among the weaker teams.
Register for personal access to all papers for just £47.99
To download papers you need a subscription to World Economics Journal.
Get access to the full 20 year archive of thousands of papers and abstracts.
Order online now for 1 years immediate access for 1 user via username/password.
You do not need a PayPal account to pay by card.
Institutional Subscriptions, Contact Us
Existing Subscriber Log-in
More Papers From These Authors in World Economics:
The Promotion Test
The collapse of broadcaster ITV Digital owing £178m to the English Football League will cause, according to the League’s Chairman, the financial failure of
up to fifty of the seventy two clubs. If this were to happen a major restructuring of English football would have to take place, including measures to make sure it could not happen again. This paper examines the underlying causes of the crisis and proposes a simple financial stability rule that would achieve this aim. The rule, which would deny promotion to any team spending over a fixed percentage (e.g. 70%) of its income on player wages, is designed to be a minimum intervention
in the operation of the football market, which has in fact worked well until now. The paper argues that because (a) financial stability is in consumers’ interests, (b) the proposed rule involves minimal intervention, and (c) since competition between clubs would remain intense, the rule would not be subject to competition law challenge.
Read Full Paper >
The Economic Impact of the World Cup
The World Cup will be the biggest sporting event of 2002, but the Japanese and
Korean governments are also hoping that it will be one of the biggest economic
events of the year. Impact studies by respected economic research institutes
predict a dramatic boost to GDP in both countries. This paper explains how
these forecasts are generated and explains the tendency for such forecasts to be
over-optimistic. The paper concludes with some policy recommendations for
governments and sporting bodies considering hosting such events.
Read Full Paper >
Up for the Cup
Measured by attendance of football fans, the FA Cup is in decline. This paper
reviews the evidence of this decline and suggests that the underlying cause may
be the growing imbalance of competition in the Cup. The paper considers the
drastic innovation that the FA introduced in 2001 to stem that decline: the
allocation of prize money. The prize money scheme is described and its likely
impact on the outcome of the competition is discussed.
Read Full Paper >
The Market for Olympic Gold Medals
From a national perspective the Sydney Olympics were almost completely predictable. Statistical modelling shows that population size and income per head provide an almost faultless method for identifying medal totals.
However, it is probably the discrepancies that are most interesting– why do some countries outperform and others underperform? Cheating, through drug abuse, is one possible explanation considered in this article.
Read Full Paper >
The Political Economy of Sport
The political constitutions of both the US and Europe provide no guidance on the role of organised sport in society. Without a proper set of rules politicians are
finding sports issues increasingly hard to handle. In the US there is widespread concern at the commercial exploitation of major league sports, particularly through the relocation of franchises. In Europe there are anxieties about the increasing polarisation of wealth and the fear that traditions built up over a century will be lost. These problems are not only likely to grow, but a new dimension will develop as sports bodies seek international expansion. In the future sports businesses may become a source of trade friction between the US and the European Union.
Read Full Paper >